Reynolds Return & Exchange Policy

We want you to love your purchase!

If you don't love it for any reason, we are happy to make an exchange within the same artist/maker brand. Please contact us within 14 days of receipt to initiate an exchange at We will send you a return label, or if you are local you can schedule a curbside exchange appointment. Products must be in new, undamaged condition. Once received, we will issue a store credit valid towards purchase within the maker/brand (minus the cost of return shipping, if applicable)

If your item arrives damaged or is incorrect, please contact us immediately at with a clear snapshot of the item (we want to be able to provide feedback to our makers). We will make every effort to correct the issue. Keep in mind, some natural variations in size, color and shape of handmade products should be expected.

Please note there are a few exceptions:

  • All edible items are final sale
  • All face masks are final sale
  • Discounted items marked as final sale cannot be returned or exchanged (unless damaged)
  • Free gifts with purchase cannot be returned or exchanged (unless damaged)

If you have any further questions, please feel free to reach out to and we will be happy to assist!